Planning a BI project

Why Does Month End Close Take So Long? 3-Day Fix

Why does month end close take so long? Usually manual pulls, one master spreadsheet, and one-person risk. Here's the path to a three-day close.

Austin Levine

·

Updated

Why does month end close take so long? For most mid-sized companies it drags for three reasons: numbers get pulled by hand from several tools, everything funnels through one master reconciliation spreadsheet, and only one person knows how that spreadsheet works. Fix those three and an eight-day close can become a three-day close.

Every finance team eventually asks the same question: why does month end close take so long? You're on day eight, the management report is due tomorrow, and you're still waiting on one file from one person because the whole close runs through a single master reconciliation spreadsheet that only they understand. The numbers won't be final until day nine or ten, and by then the meeting where they mattered is almost on top of you.

If that's your month, the delay is baked into how the work is wired. Your team could be working flat out and the close would still take eight days. Below is a plain look at the three things that cost you the days, what a fast close looks like instead, and what to ask for first.

Key takeaways

  • Month-end close drags for three reasons: manual data pulls, one master reconciliation spreadsheet, and one person who knows it.

  • Fix those three and an eight-day close can become a three-day close.

  • The master spreadsheet sits in the middle of the process, so every delay lands on that one file.

  • A fast close changes what happens at each step, not how many hours people work.

Why does month end close take so long in the first place?

There are three usual causes, and most companies have all three at once.

The first is manual pulls. Someone logs into the accounting tool, exports a file. Someone else pulls payroll. A third person copies numbers out of the sales tool. Every export is a person doing work by hand, and every one is a place a number can go stale or land in the wrong cell.

The second is the master reconciliation spreadsheet. All those exports get pasted into one big file that ties the close together. It has years of formulas in it, tabs on top of tabs, and it's where every number finally agrees. It also breaks if someone types over a formula, and it grows slower and heavier every quarter.

The third is one-person risk. That spreadsheet lives in one person's head. They know which tab feeds which, why that odd adjustment is there, and what to fix when a total looks off. If they're on holiday or out sick, the close stops. Nobody else can safely touch the file.

None of these is a people problem. They're a setup problem, and a setup can be changed.

How long should month end close take?

Here's the benchmark worth aiming for. A close that takes about eight days is common and widely treated as acceptable, while the teams that finish in under three days sit at the top of their field (SolveXia). So if you're at eight to ten days, you're in the normal range, and there's a clear tier above you that closes in less than half the time.

The gap between an eight-day close and a three-day close is almost never a smarter accountant. It's the wiring. Fast closers have taken the manual pulls and the one master spreadsheet out of the critical path, so the numbers arrive on their own and reconciliation is a report they read, not a file they rebuild every month.

What slows the financial close process down the most?

If you can only look at one thing, look at the master spreadsheet. It sits in the middle of the financial close process, so every delay upstream and every error inside it lands on the same file, and that file is your bottleneck.

Two numbers explain why it's risky. 94% of business spreadsheets used in decision-making contain errors (Panko et al.), so the file your whole close depends on almost certainly has a wrong formula somewhere. And 82% of teams say data silos get in the way of their work (ZoomInfo), which is what all those separate exports are: numbers trapped in tools that don't talk to each other, copied across by hand.

Put those together and you get the real cost. It isn't only the extra days. It's that the number you carry into the leadership review came out of a hand-built file that probably has an error in it, and everyone in the room half-knows it. That's why only 40% of executives say they always trust their data (Talend). A slow close and a doubted number tend to be the same problem seen from two sides.

What does a three-day close look like?

A fast close changes what happens at each step, not how many hours people work. Here's the before and after.

Step

Ten-day close

Three-day close

Getting the numbers

Exported by hand from each tool

Pulled in automatically, on a schedule

Reconciliation

One master spreadsheet, edited live

A report that runs off a governed model

Who can run it

One person who knows the file

Written down, several people can run it

If that person is out

The close stalls

The close still runs

The management report

Rebuilt late, numbers move

Same numbers every time, ready on day three

The shift is simple to describe. The source tools feed a central place on their own, reconciliation becomes a report you open instead of a file you assemble, and no single person is the only one who can finish the month.

What should you fix first?

You don't need to rebuild everything at once. Ask for these three, in this order, and treat them as your month end close checklist.

First, kill the manual pulls. Get each source tool feeding numbers in automatically so no one is exporting and pasting by hand. This alone takes real days out, because the pulls are usually the slowest and most error-prone part.

Second, get the numbers out of one spreadsheet and into a governed model. That means one place where the definitions live, where a total is calculated the same way every time, and where reconciliation shows up as a report rather than a live file anyone can overwrite. This is where the trust comes back, because leadership number and the finance number finally come from the same source.

Third, remove the one-person risk. Once the pulls and the model are set up and documented, the close stops living in one head. More than one person can run it, and a holiday or a sick day no longer stops the month.

If you want a read on where your own close is losing days, the free Power BI Governance and Cost Scorecard gives you a five-minute score and your top three risks. And if your month-end still runs on manual exports and one master spreadsheet, book a scoping call and we'll map the path to a three-day close on your real setup.

How does the reconciliation get automated?

This is the one place worth going a level deeper, kept short. When people hear automate they expect a big rebuild, and it's smaller than that.

Each of your source tools, the accounting platform, payroll, the sales tool, has a way to send its data out on a schedule instead of you exporting it. Those feeds land in one central model. The model keeps the definitions and the logic that used to live in the spreadsheet tabs, so a reconciliation is calculated the same way every time and shown as a report you read. When a total looks off, you can trace it back to the source instead of hunting through cells. Your team stops rebuilding the file every month and starts reviewing a report that's already done. That's the whole move, and it's the difference between a ten-day close and a three-day one.

Frequently asked questions

How long should month end close take? About eight days is common and treated as acceptable, and teams that close in under three days are considered top performers (SolveXia). If you're at eight to ten days you're in the normal range, with clear room to move faster by fixing the wiring.

Why does month end close take so long even after buying new tools? Because the tools didn't remove the two real bottlenecks: numbers still get exported and pasted by hand, and one master reconciliation spreadsheet still ties everything together. New software only speeds up the close once the manual pulls and the single spreadsheet come out of the critical path.

Is the master reconciliation spreadsheet really the problem? It's usually the biggest one. It's where every upstream delay and every copy-paste error collects, and 94% of decision spreadsheets contain errors (Panko et al.). It also tends to live in one person's head, so it's both your slowest step and your largest single-person risk.

What's one-person risk in the close? It's when only one person understands the master spreadsheet, so the close depends entirely on them being available. If they're out, nobody else can safely run the month. Documenting the process and moving reconciliation into a governed model removes that dependency.

Do we have to replace all our finance tools to close faster? No. Most of the days come back from two changes: feeding the source tools in automatically instead of by hand, and moving reconciliation out of one spreadsheet into a governed model. You keep your accounting platform and build the fast path around it.

How do we get a trusted single number for leadership? Have the management report and the finance numbers come from the same governed model rather than a separate spreadsheet. When both read from one source with one definition per number, the two stop disagreeing and the management report lines up with the ledger.

Read next: How long should month end close take, and how to get there and You bought Power BI and finance still lives in Excel. Here's why.

Is your Power BI set up the right way?

1

Book 45 minutes and tell us what you want looked at.

2

We walk through your reports and setup with you, live.

3

Within two working days, you get our plan in writing.

Is your Power BI set up the right way?

1

Book 45 minutes and tell us what you want looked at.

2

We walk through your reports and setup with you, live.

3

Within two working days, you get our plan in writing.

Is your Power BI set up the right way?

1

Book 45 minutes and tell us what you want looked at.

2

We walk through your reports and setup with you, live.

3

Within two working days, you get our plan in writing.

CaseWhen is a Berlin BI consultancy that builds reporting that leaders can trust, on the Microsoft stack: Power BI, Fabric and Azure.

Berlin, Germany

© CaseWhen Consulting GmbH

English

CaseWhen is a Berlin BI consultancy that builds reporting that leaders can trust, on the Microsoft stack: Power BI, Fabric and Azure.

Berlin, Germany

© CaseWhen Consulting GmbH

English

CaseWhen is a Berlin BI consultancy that builds reporting that leaders can trust, on the Microsoft stack: Power BI, Fabric and Azure.

Berlin, Germany

© CaseWhen Consulting GmbH

English